Accessibility links

Breaking News

Debating Room

Former Afghan President Hamid Karzai

Former Afghan President Hamid Karzai has attracted criticism for opposing the incumbent, Ashraf Ghani.

Afghan lawmakers, political commentators, and listeners participating in a recent Radio Free Afghanistan call-in show, On The Waves Of Freedom, urged Karzai to let Afghanistan's national unity government work toward fulfilling the promises it made during its election campaign last year.

Sami, a Radio Free Afghanistan listener in the southeastern Afghan province of Logar, said former Karzai confidants such as Omar Daudzai, Abdul Karim Khurram, and Rangin Dadfar Spanta have now set up shop at the former president's Kabul home.

"They are actively conspiring against the government of President Ashraf Ghani," said Sami, who goes by one name only. "But we elected this government through our ballots, and we want it to work toward delivering on its promises. It is in our right to demand it do so."

In interviews and opinion pieces last week, Karzai and his spokesman criticized Ghani's outreach to Pakistan. Aimal Faizi, a former Afghan presidential spokesman who still works for Karzai, said, "The policies that Arg, the Afghan presidential palace in Kabul, is peddling with Islamabad -- particularly its dealings with the Pakistani military -- have caused a deep and unfortunate rupture between the current and former Afghan presidents."

Lawmaker Khalid Pashtun, who represents the southern province of Kandahar in the lower house of Afghan parliament, said parliamentarians and officials loyal to Karzai are openly talking about the possibility of a new government later this year.

"In parliament, some of our [pro-Karzai] colleagues are openly warning us of the impending collapse of the national unity government," he said. "We are urging Ghani and his partner, chief executive Abdullah Abdullah, to pay attention and move swiftly to end the patronage system that Karzai established."

Pashtun said that in recent weeks some pro-Karzai commanders have defected to the Taliban in the restive southern province of Uruzgan.

"In the Khas Uruzgan and Deh Rawud districts of the province, local forces loyal to Karzai who were manning important security check posts deliberately surrendered to the Taliban," he said. "Unless Ghani ends the patronage system that prospered under the former leader, such incidents will continue."

Gul Badshah Majeed, a lawmaker, said factional leaders and warlords were empowered and imposed as national leaders in Afghanistan during Karzai's 13 years in power from 2001 to 2014.

"People are surprised to discover the extent of corruption in the previous government," he said. "Even now, those same powerful people are vying to preserve power by clinging to their posts."

Wadir Safi, a Kabul University professor, said Ghani needs to move quickly to rid Afghanistan's political systems of the ills afflicted upon it during Karzai's reign. "There are concerns that insecurity, the worsening economy, corruption, bad governance, and the [political] system's failure to deliver might provoke a general revolt," he said.

Every Thursday, millions of Afghans in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iran, and Tajikistan tune in to On The Waves Of Freedom. The weekly two-hour radio show is known for its analysis and political commentary, and is a flagship program of Radio Free Afghanistan, locally known as Radio Azadi.

as/fg

Afghan Forces operation against the Taliban and their IMU allies.

There has been a lot of trouble across northern Afghanistan in recent months and one reason is the arrival of militants from the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan (IMU).

When the Pakistani military started a large-scale operation in North Waziristan last spring it chased IMU militants from their safe havens and sent them, with their families, across the border into northern Afghanistan. Since then they have spread out from the Badakhshan Province in the east to Baghdis Province in the west.

Afghan officials, particularly those in the affected provinces, have noticed an upsurge in violence across the north during these last 12 months and have linked recent fighting to the arrival of "foreign militants."

RFE/RL's Turkmen Service, known locally as Azatlyk, organized a panel discussion to talk about the presence of militants from Central Asia, including the IMU, in northern Afghanistan, their activities, their motives, and their potential threat to regions outside Afghanistan.

Azatlyk director Muhammad Tahir moderated the talk. Taking part were Afghan parliament deputy Shinkey Zehin Korakhil; Abubakar Siddique, author of the acclaimed book The Pashtun Question and chief editor of RFE/RL's Gandhara website; and I had some things to say also. The panel also heard taped comments from Afghan presidential security adviser Mohammad Hanif Atmer; General Ghulam Heydar Haydari, the head of Afghanistan's national armed forces in the northern provinces; and Bashir Ahmad Tayanch, an Afghan lawmaker from Faryab Province.

There was steady fighting in five northern Afghan provinces during 2014: from west to east they are Baghdis, Faryab, Jowzjan, Kunduz, and Badakhshan. Most of that fighting was on the level of raids -- attacks on government positions, involving a handful of fighters, on occasions maybe a couple of dozen, and at the end of the battle the enemy withdrew.

Attacks this year have involved more militants and they are often attempting to capture and hold ground.

Some of the heaviest fighting this year has taken place in northeastern Afghanistan, near the city of Kunduz (where fighting is still in progress), in the province of the same name, and in the Jurm district of Badakhshan Province, and the Marchak district of Baghdis Province.

National security adviser Atmer said: "We are not dealing only with local enemies. Our fight in northern and eastern Afghanistan is against global and regional terrorist groups."

For his part, General Haydari said: "Lately foreign terrorists are gathering in Badakhshan. Those terrorists include Chechens, Tajiks, even Kazakhs and Uzbeks from the Jundallah group, not only the terrorists but they also bring their wives and children. During the last year they're engaged in actions in Khostak that are against the government. They specialize in making bombs and train suicide bombers."

Tayanch, the lawmaker from Faryab, said, "Our estimates suggest that there are between 1,500 to 2,000 Taliban militants in Faryab Province, nearly 50 to 100 of them are foreign fighters...."

In an earlier report from Qishloq Ovozi, we heard commander Bobi from a local paramilitary force, the Arbaky, in Faryab say in the neighboring Jowzjan Province, that people "from Uzbekistan...nearly 70 families" had arrived recently. "We heard they came from Waziristan," he added.

Parliament member Korakhil said Afghan officials had a good idea what would happen when Pakistan started its military offensive in North Waziristan last year and the Afghan government warned of the consequences. "The surprise is nobody took these warnings seriously and now everybody is saying 'what's going on' with our northern border areas with the Central Asian countries," Korakhil said. "When Pakistan forced them out from the periphery, where else could they go?"

North Waziristan has been the main IMU sanctuary since late 2001, when U.S. bombing chased the group from the northeastern Afghan regions where fighting has picked up this year.

As RFE/RL's Siddique said, "They are looking for a new sanctuary in Afghanistan now and that's why, there is, they're trying to carve out a sanctuary in Badakhshan, which is strategically located close to Tajikistan, bordering Tajikistan and also Pakistan, and also in Kunduz."

The same could be said of IMU fighters further west and commander Bobi's comment indicates some IMU members have managed to find at least temporary haven for themselves and their families in Jowzjan Province.

Siddique emphasized though that the IMU, or its offshoots such as "the Islamic Jihad Union, Jamaat Ansarullah, Jundullah, and Jund al-Khalifa," seem to be coincidental participants in the hostilities in northern Afghanistan rather than Taliban reinforcements called in for the spring offensive. "The IMU in essence is now this wandering group of militants" in northern Afghanistan, Siddique concluded.

Wandering, but still well armed and with years of combat and tactical experience, which they are now using to help to help the only group in Afghanistan that can shelter them -- the Taliban.

But another unintended consequence of the Pakistani security operation in North Waziristan is that the IMU militants, for the first time in a decade, are present in large numbers along the border with Central Asia. As the group passed the years in North Waziristan their ultimate goal of overthrowing the governments in Central Asia (Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, and Kyrgyzstan at least) seemed to have waned and been replaced by more immediate battles alongside their Taliban allies in Pakistan and Afghanistan.

The forced eviction from Pakistan could refocus the group's goal.

Lawmaker Korakhil said she believes the IMU is now looking at Central Asia, and another country, but she added that is small consolation for Afghanistan at the moment. "It's true that to reach Central Asia they have to provide [for themselves] a safe home for them in Afghanistan so they can target the Central Asian countries or even some part of China, but that doesn't mean they will not attack Afghans and you can see what's happening with Afghan security," Korakhil said.

However, the IMU does not appear to be acting as a cohesive organization at the moment.

IMU leader Usman Ghazi declared his allegiance to the Islamic State group in late September 2014. But as Korakhil noted, the IMU had been an ally of the Taliban for nearly two decades and her information from northern Afghanistan indicated there has been no change in ties between the two militant groups.

Ghazi is, in any case, the third IMU leader since 2009, when the group's charismatic spiritual leader, Tahir Yuldash, was killed in a missile strike in South Waziristan (his successor, Usman Odil, was killed in a U.S. drone strike in North Waziristan in April 2012). It is unclear how many IMU fighters still support Ghazi.

The panelists addressed many other issues during the discussion and you can listen to full roundtable here:

please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:41:56 0:00
Direct link

Apologies for the quality of the audio in the comments from our Afghan guest, we are working on improving our connections to Afghanistan.

-- Bruce Pannier

Load more

XS
SM
MD
LG